Nicely done.  I was really shocked when Edward called Carlisle a murderer.  I think that will have struck a nerve for sure.  Why is it we always hurt the ones we love the most?

And can't wait for more.  I'm excited to see what kind of vamp Bella will become.

great chapter

AWESOME CHAPTER

I think Carlisle put Edward soundly in his place. Good for him. I am looking forward to seeing what newborn Bella is like. I hope she gives Edward hell for a while.

I plan on seeing remember me... i read the original script and it should be a really good but kinda sad movie... cant wait... good job on the chapter btw. update again soon plz

Wow! Ok so was a little worried what Edward would do once he got there but I am so relieved to see that it went relativly well. I do believe Carlisle and Edward will both live with guilt for awhile but Bella will do a great deal to aleviate that gift. LoL...I wonder if Bella will put Edward thru the wall once she learns he lied to her. I know she will kiss the boo boo better but I do smile at the possibility. =) Can't wait to see how Bella's first days will be.

Emmett and Rose provide the comic relief, but it's Carlisle -- still -- who's the moral center of this story.  I like your Carlisle a lot.  This is very good:  "Don't talk to me about betrayal, Edward. Not unless you want to talk about it on a two-way street."  Edward's certainty and outrage and the beginning of the conversation is slowly defused by Carlisle.  And while you don't leave me (or Bella) hanging off a a cliff, I am certainly impatient to find out how Bella's change is going (will we get an Esme POV?) and how Edward and she will react when they finally meet again. 

Another Hit. Congrts. Keep uo the good work. As per your question...I'm still debating.

Poor Carlisle. I'm he did what he did though. I also loved Esme's POV.

Wow, ok now it makes sense why he chose to ask her then.  I think he did the right thing to have her change happen now, beofre Edward gets there.  I think he would be too distraught over the change otherwise.

Another fantastic chapter, but I'm anxious to move on.

 

wow... what??!!!  Why is Carlisle going to change her now?  What does he think that will do to her?  Will she be mentally unstable as a vamp like Victoria?

Still loving this, I'm moving on ....

Did she see something in Florida?  Or something coming for them?

So glad i'm still behind, I'm moving on ....