That was so sad.  I cried with her.  I'm a big girl, but I never had to experience that kind of judgement from loved ones and I'm very sorry that you did.  Another very very good chapter.  Can't wait for the next one!

AWWWwwww!  Nice Daddy!

Trying to type while crying isn't easy, but I need to tell you thanks for writing this story again!  I think that the majority of us who are curvy have had to deal with family members who are more than a little judgmental.  It hurts even worse coming from them.  Still keeping it real, that is what keeps me reading!  And can I just say, I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Charlie!  Can I just have him for my own dad????? PLEASE!!!  Ok, so I have reached an all time low, wanting a fictional character for my dad.  The Edward, Jacob, Rose phone calls.....HILARIOUS!!! 

I don't even know what to say about this chapter.  Some people shouldn't be allowed to talk no matter how old they are.  Thank goodness Charlie understands and stands up for his daughter.  I was beginning to think that things were starting to look up for Bella and all these new friends would boost her self-image.  One step forward and twenty back, thanks to good ole' Grandpa.

Look forward to reading more!

I sooooo can relate to this story! And it was my HUSBAND'S grandfather who constantly ragged on me about my weight. I finally had enough one day, and told him "grandpa, if you don't hush about my weight, I'm gonna sit on you!" and just laughed and laughed. He never said another word about my weight! I guess he was scared I was gonna actually do it......I just might have!! Enough is enough....

Wow! What a old geezer Grandpa is. Poor Bella! Can't wait for more!

The Edward/Jacob/Bella love triangle is just so -yawn- that simple friendly rivalry is a good thing.

Kiss on the hand is nice, but should be followed up with kiss on the cheek to make intentions clear.  ;)

Edward and Jacob are friends! Yay! Thank you, that's a welcome change. And the party was awesome. Edward is so sweet, I hope annoying Tanya is going to take a road trip to Tibet or Timbuktu soon ;-)

I'm all for the lack of conflict between Edward and Jacob.  Can't stand him in the books, and then so many write him as a bad guy that it's hard to ever like him.  But this was is good.  Athletic competition is much more fun:)

I feel so bad for Bella though.  She's so insecure that Edward's gestures are either being scrutinized serverly or she's not seeing them at all.  I am glad for Rose though.  Perhaps she can help the two along, help Bella with her self-esteem and help Edward understand a little better.  Can't wait for your next update:)

I love that Edward & Jacob are friends for once! its about time.

The kiss on the hand was sweet :')  Can't wait to see where Bella & Edward go from here.

 

i know...i liked the jake and edward bond!  hehehe!

I wanna kick tanya's ass just because I hate that character!

 

I am still loving rose and seriously...................the details she knows cold really hurt bella...I hope she doesn't hurt her or spill Bella's secrets!

HAHAHA in your face tanya!!!!

 

Great chapter or should I say -- LIKE great chapter. LOL Tanya is just such a loser!